In a recent development, the European Union has formally charged Meta with violations of its Digital Markets Act (DMA). This is the second such charge issued in as many weeks, marking a significant move by the European Commission to hold tech giants accountable for their practices.
The Issue at Hand
The core of the problem lies in Meta’s “pay or consent” advertising model, which was launched last year for Facebook and Instagram users. The European Commission found that this model infringes on Article 5(2) of the DMA by not offering users a third option that allows for less data usage in ad targeting while still providing a free service.
Regulators discovered that Meta’s advertising model presents users with a “binary choice” – they must either pay a monthly subscription fee for an ad-free experience or consent to the ad-supported version. This lack of flexibility denies users the option to choose a free version that uses minimal personal data for ad targeting while maintaining an equivalent experience to the personalized ads service.
Commission’s Stance
Margrethe Vestager, who leads the region’s competition policy, emphasized the importance of empowering citizens to control their data and opt for a less personalized ads experience. The commission believes that Meta’s current advertising model does not comply with the DMA and restricts users from freely consenting to the combination of their personal data.
Under Article 5(2) of the DMA, gatekeepers like Meta are required to obtain users’ consent before combining their personal data across different services. If users decline this consent, gatekeepers must provide access to a less personalized but equivalent alternative. Conditional use of service or functionalities based on user consent is prohibited under the DMA.
Response from Meta
Meta’s spokesperson, Matthew Pollard, stated that the subscription option for an ad-free experience aligns with the DMA guidelines. Meta looks forward to engaging in constructive dialogue with the European Commission to address the concerns raised in the investigation.
Potential Consequences
If Meta is found guilty of violating the DMA upon the conclusion of the investigation next year, the EU could impose a fine of up to 10 percent of Meta’s total worldwide revenue. This penalty could amount to as much as $13.4 billion, based on Meta’s projected revenue for 2023. Furthermore, if Meta continues to infringe on the DMA, the fine could increase to 20 percent.
Meta is not the only company facing charges under the DMA, as Apple was also targeted for its App Store policies. The EU’s crackdown on tech giants reflects a growing trend towards holding these companies accountable for their practices and ensuring fair competition in the digital market.
The EU’s charges against Meta highlight the importance of data privacy and user consent in the digital age. As tech companies continue to expand their reach and influence, regulatory bodies play a crucial role in safeguarding consumers’ rights and promoting a more transparent and equitable digital ecosystem.
Leave a Reply