The Broad Definition of Immersive Sims: A Case Study by Raphael Colantonio

Raphael Colantonio, founder of Arkane Studios, challenges the traditional definition of immersive sims in a recent interview with PC Gamer. While many players may not classify games like Skyrim and Baldur’s Gate 3 as immersive sims, Colantonio argues otherwise. He believes that the genre encompasses a broader range of gameplay elements than typically thought.

Colantonio explains that immersive sims extend beyond the traditional first-person RPGs associated with the genre. He points to games developed by Bethesda and Obsidian as prime examples of immersive sims, citing their heavy reliance on simulation mechanics. According to Colantonio, even seemingly simple acts like fooling a merchant by placing a bucket on their head qualify as immersive sim experiences.

The Arkane veteran emphasizes the blurred lines between different sub-genres within immersive sims. He suggests that both action-oriented and RPG-focused games can fall under the immersive sim umbrella. By highlighting Bethesda’s commitment to simulation in their games, Colantonio challenges the notion that immersive sims are limited to specific gameplay styles.

Beyond Bethesda’s titles, Colantonio recognizes Larian Studios’ Baldur’s Gate 3 as another example of an immersive sim. He acknowledges the game’s turn-based nature and unconventional player choices, such as completing the game as four cats or a wheel of cheese. This flexibility in gameplay approaches reinforces Colantonio’s belief in the open-ended nature of immersive sims.

In concluding his thoughts on the genre, Colantonio acknowledges the ongoing debate surrounding the definition of immersive sims. He highlights the subjective nature of classifying games within this category, noting that what constitutes an immersive sim for one person may differ for another. This ambiguity invites further discussion about the boundaries and possibilities of the genre.

Raphael Colantonio’s perspective challenges conventional notions of immersive sims, urging players to reconsider the diverse range of experiences that fall under this genre. By embracing the complexity and flexibility of immersive sims, developers and players alike can explore new and innovative gameplay mechanics that push the boundaries of traditional gaming genres.